Examining Some Assumptions about ‘Community’ in Online Learning
Posted on February 29, 2008 by Barbara Macaulay
Here I go, breaking every blogging rule in the book, but some subjects just demand a little more room for a few more words. So with my apologies…
Here’s a fact that hasn’t been discussed previously on this blog: Online student attrition rates are 10% to 20% higher than for students attending face to face classes in higher education. It’s a fact that has led some critics of distance education to suggest that online learning can never attain the satisfaction levels of a traditional approach. Among online proponents and academic researchers, this fact has spawned countless studies in a quest to isolate the factor or factors responsible for this outcome among distance learners.
Most of the research studies start with one or more reasonable hypotheses: physical distance from campus must be the cause; psychological or transactional distance and separations of time and space may be at the root of this issue; the limitations of technology to recreate a sense of community akin to a college campus are at fault.
So far, in my opinion, none of these theories have been supported by the research. And, in support of that opinion, here’s an abstract of a recent study entitled, “Perceptions of Online Course Communications and Collaboration.” While this is a report about a survey principally intended to determine how gender and course difficulty levels may affect online students’ satisfaction levels, it provides a fairly comprehensive review of related studies focused on achievement and retention factors for online learners. It says distance, physical or otherwise, is not a factor and that satisfaction levels and a sense of community are achieved equally in online and face to face offerings.
Still, even among experienced classroom academics in higher education, there remains a level of skepticism about the online world’s ability to achieve a real sense of community for students. I have never shared this suspicion and now that I am again teaching online, I’m more confirmed than ever in my belief that rich community experiences can be created and offered to online students. So then, what accounts for this disconnect; how is it that experienced faculty can hold two distinct impressions separated by such a wide disparity in view?
In this post, I want to share with you what I know – and what I acknowledge none of us knows for sure – about online community building. And, I want to ask any and all online students, whether attending UMassOnline or any other institution, to tell us their own version of the contemporary reality because quite frankly I think they are more of an authority on this subject than anyone.
Here’s what I believe:
Assumptions are made about what “community” means within courses and sometimes there is a misguided sense that community building takes place in all courses that are face-to-face and not at all in courses online. Obviously, the truth is somewhere in between and resides with a faculty member’s way of designing a course. Things that can build that sense of belonging, that esprit de corps, are guided discussions, group exercises, team projects, debates, role playing, brainstorming, group research and the like—and all of these things can be done online.
We don’t know if students, particularly adult and continuing education students, consciously seek community when they sign up for courses or apply to be admitted to programs. My guess is that the first order of priority for them is more practical—complete a course, meet a program requirement, get a degree, and meet job requirements. I think meeting people and feeling a part of something bigger than a course is an unexpected bonus for them. Adult students know that in attending part-time, online, face-to-face, and/or blended courses, they have had to opt out of the traditional program opportunities, but they do so consciously, as other realities in their lives take precedence.
Adult students have communities elsewhere in their lives –families, neighborhoods, etc. On campus students also would probably tell you that their communities are formed outside of class.
I think that there will always be students who feel a part of “something” when they are students and those who feel as though they are on the outside looking in.
Clearly we need to think about the levels of community formation that interest students. My suspicion is that these include knowledge communities, program communities, and social communities. Probably the first two can be formed online as well as they are formed face-to-face. And, as with blended learning, we need to think about whether we are talking about community at the course level and/or at the program level.
Now it’s your turn…
Tags: Online Learning, UMassOnlinePermalink | Trackback |
Print This Post
- What is an Online Course Offered by UMassOnline Like?
- On the importance of orientations…
- The Conversation on Critical Thinking Joins Local and Global Voices
- UMassOnline and UMass Lowell Announce Innovative Model
- Test, Test, Test – Is It That Important?
Comments
2 Responses to “Examining Some Assumptions about ‘Community’ in Online Learning”
Share your comment:
Review our comment policy
|
|
Explore UMassOnline
Millions of minds. Thousands of Possibilities. Endless Opportunity. Learn how global students are woven together by a common thread, a quality education. Click here to watch the UMassOnline One World Class video.
This post is a bit ‘old’ to comment on, but I will do so anyway
Having taken a number of online classes, I am confident to pronounce that I would not feel comfortable taking a whole curriculum of courses online - and keep in mind that I am the technology junkie in my classes! There needs to be some human interaction in online courses to build that community. Some institutions like some of the online library school programs require that students in a specific cohort take certain courses as ‘bootcamp’ courses face to face for 2 weeks at the beginning, and 1 week/semester subsequent visits to the campus.
Is this a pain? sure it is! especially if the campus is in the middle of nowhere, but it’s beneficial.
As a current student of instructional design an president of the graduate student association, I am seeing that I interact differently with classmates that I see face to face (even if I am not a friend of theirs) than classmates online. Also, as workign adults both I and my classmates don’t have a lot of time to socialize and create those bonds.
To create a way for people to meet and exchange useful information I’ve created an online social network (private) for current students and alumni. Students who are face to face can get on the boards and see what fellow students are sharing and get answers to their own questions.
Online students can use the social network to keep in contact and stay in the loop in between semesters when they do not have access to the Learnign Management System (blackboard, moodle, etc). This creates bonds and allows people to keep in contact both while in the program and when they graduate.
While most people join an educational program or online class to learn some new skills, if certain conditions are not met - i.e. the class is too impersonal, you don’t know your classmates, faculty are too robotic and boring, etc. you might think twice about staying in college A and you might consider trying college B.
Universities are not just in the business of dishing out knowledge, they exist to also create community - either through a physical campus and the ameneties that that campus provides or a virtual social network. Knowledge can be had at any barnes and noble - just go read a book. People go to school to engage with others and community is central to that.
my two cents as a life long learner
Your comments may be late but I appreciate them. This is a topic that needs mroe exploration and research in my opinion (not that I have the time currently to conduct any studies myself…sigh…).
The whole notion of the importance of community for adult learners in continuing higher education was an emerging theme of my dissertation (sadly, this predated online education). This is an important area of focus for higher education as you aptly point out.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts and what you are doing as a student to meet some of the need. Very valuable two cents, I would say!!
Barbara